ETSY HELP, MADE SIMPLE
Can someone review my Etsy shop and tell me what to fix?
Yes. A useful shop review should show you what is unclear, explain why it matters, and help you pick a few changes. Start with one listing, your recent visits and orders, and the question you are stuck on. You can use the checks below yourself, then ask for a second set of eyes.
You don’t need a list of 50 problems. You need a clear place to start.
Let’s work through itGet useful shop feedback
Here’s where I’d start.
I’d begin where a buyer begins: the first photo and the offer. Then I’d look at the numbers. A quiet shop needs a different plan from a busy shop where people leave without buying.
Bring one clear question
Share a public listing link, your product, and what you have tried. Add visits and orders from the same period if you have them. Hide customer names, addresses, and order details in screenshots.
Look at it like a buyer
Can someone tell what is included, how big it is, and when they will get it? Check the photo, title, price, delivery details, and shop information together.
Choose three fixes
Separate a missing fact from a test. A missing size needs adding. A new main photo is a test. Save the old version, note the date, and review the same numbers later.
LET’S MAKE IT REAL
A sample shop review: a handmade tote.
This is a teaching example, not a review of a real shop or a promise of more sales.
| What I notice | Why it matters | What I’d do next |
|---|---|---|
| The tote is folded in every photo. | I cannot see its shape or strap length. | Add a full view and a photo showing scale. |
| The size says “large.” | Large means different things to different people. | Add the actual width, height, and strap drop. |
| A pouch appears beside the tote. | I am not sure whether the pouch is included. | State exactly what the buyer gets. |
| The shop has visits but few orders. | Traffic alone does not explain why people leave. | Check the offer and search terms before adding ads. |
My first three fixes: show the whole tote, add measurements, and make the contents clear. Then decide what to test.
PUT IT TO WORK
Use this to ask for useful feedback.
My public listing link: [link] I sell: [product and who it is for] The problem I want help with: [one question] Time period: [start and end dates] Visits and orders in that period: [totals, if available] What I have already tried: [changes and dates] What I need next: Help me choose the first three things to fix.
Replace the bracketed details with your own.
YOUR NEXT SMALL WIN
Pick one thing to work on today.
Use this checklist as a starting point. You don’t need a perfect shop to take the next useful step.
Checkmarks stay on this page while you use it. No signup needed.
0 of 4 checked
EXPERIENCE BEHIND THE ADVICE
15+ years on Etsy.
A clearer next step for you.
I’m LL Divens, founder of Handmade & Beyond and Etsy Games. I’ve built and grown Etsy shops in handmade, digital products, and vintage.
- $550,000+ in Etsy sales
- Thousands of Etsy sellers helped through coaching and education
- MBA in Marketing from Florida Tech
- 400+ YouTube videos and 400+ podcast episodes
I’ve helped thousands of sellers through coaching and education. My goal with feedback is to make the next action clear enough that you can actually do it.
Read my story and credentialsFROM ETSY GAMES MEMBERS
You don’t have to figure it out alone.
“LL is a tremendous motivator, hugely knowledgeable in all things Etsy and AI, and provides helpful feedback.”
An excerpt from a public Etsy Games member review. Rating checked October 21, 2026. Read the full reviews on Skool ↗
Want a second set of eyes on your shop?
Bring your listing and your question to Etsy Games. The full-support plan includes personal feedback so you can work out what to improve next.
Ask your questions. Learn with other sellers. Keep making progress.
$10/month
- Personalized feedback and support
- Done-for-you Etsy titles and tags
- A one-to-one onboarding call
- Courses, guides, and AI resources
- Community and Etsy challenges
Community and challenges only? The intro plan is $8/month. Both plans have yearly discounts.
A free trial is currently available. Check Skool for current pricing and trial terms.
A FEW MORE QUESTIONS
Before you get back to your shop.
Can I review my own Etsy shop for free?
Yes. Use this checklist and Etsy’s shop critique guide. Ask someone unfamiliar with your product what they think they would receive. Their questions can reveal gaps you missed.
What should I include in a shop-review request?
Include your public shop or listing link, what you sell, your question, and what you have already tried. Share relevant totals from a clear time period, without private customer data.
Does Etsy Games include personal feedback?
The full-support plan includes personalized feedback and support. The intro plan includes the community and challenges. A shop review is not a promise of sales or a separate unlimited consulting service.
YOUR NEXT STEP STARTS HERE
Less guessing. More progress.
Get practical help and a community that keeps you moving.
Explore Etsy Games